Three outlets that ate through opening night Sunday agree the $6.49 Winter Wonderland Express is the treat to beat. They split hard on Mickey the Elf, and one new dessert was pulled before Disney Food Blog got a bite.
Mickey's Very Merry Christmas Party opened Sunday, Nov. 8, at Magic Kingdom, and the first reviews of its party-only food are in. The early winner is a tiny yule log.
The Winter Wonderland Express at Main Street Bakery costs $6.49. It's hazelnut mousse and crunchy feuilletine with panna cotta, shaped like a single-serve Buche de Noel. WDW News Today ranked it 6 out of 7 and called it "a surprisingly sophisticated dessert."
Disney Food Blog called it "a great sweet-and-salty treat." MickeyBlog went with "super delicious." Fan sites rarely agree this fast.
Mickey the Elf ($7.99) at Cosmic Ray's Starlight Cafe is the fight. WDWNT gave the vanilla mousse elf hat a 3 and called it "photogenic but gross." Disney Food Blog found a gooey cake-batter layer at the bottom and said, "We devoured this one." MickeyBlog called it "a great addition." Two to one for the elf.
One new treat may be hard to find. A Cast Member at Pecos Bill Tall Tale Inn and Cafe told Disney Food Blog they had to stop selling the Pluto Reindeer Cake ($6.29) for now. Disney hasn't said why.
Our math: the 10 new party snacks and counter-service dishes with prices add up to $81.50 before tax, if Pluto comes back.
Here's Gotta Go Orlando's full look at this year's party menu:
What are the best treats at Mickey's Very Merry Christmas Party 2026?
The opening-night favorites:
Winter Wonderland Express, $6.49 (Main Street Bakery): The consensus pick. MickeyBlog compared the crunchy base to a KitKat.
Peppermint Bark Cola Slushy, $6.99 (Astrofizz): Frozen Coca-Cola with a chocolate-peppermint swirl. WDWNT gave it a 6 and compared it to "an Andes mint meets a peppermint Oreo."
Mexican Hot Chocolate Churro Loops, $7.49 (Pecos Bill): Six loops with a marshmallow cream dip. Disney Food Blog called them "a definite step up from the usual park churro."
Mongolian Beef Bao, $9.99 (Sleepy Hollow Refreshments): Three small bao, not one big one. Disney Food Blog loved the soft dough but wanted more filling.
Gingerbread Cheesecake Beignets, $8.79 (Golden Oak Outpost): WDWNT called them a must-try and said to bring "lots and lots of napkins." Disney Food Blog was let down that the cheesecake sits under the beignets, not inside.
Which Very Merry party snacks should you skip?
Sugar Cookie Soda, $5.99 (The Friar's Nook): Coca-Cola with cookie butter syrup and cold foam. WDWNT gave it a 3: "Personally, we'd skip it." Disney Food Blog liked it better than the Gingerbread Cola ($5.99), which reminded its reporter of children's medicine.
Tostada de Nochebuena, $13.99 (Pecos Bill): Disney Food Blog's biggest letdown. The smoked pork was "very over-salted."
Holiday Brownie Sundae, $9.29 (Plaza Ice Cream Parlor): Stale brownie, mostly vanilla, Disney Food Blog said.
Very Merry Mickey Sundae, $7.99 (Storybook Treats): Tasty, but "about 99% vanilla ice cream for eight dollars," per Disney Food Blog.
Minnie Cocoa Cake, $6.49 (Casey's Corner): Your call. WDWNT gave it a 5 and MickeyBlog loved it. Disney Food Blog found it too sweet, with marshmallow filling closer to "a sugary paste."
What are the free treats at Mickey's Very Merry Christmas Party?
Your party ticket covers a cookie or pretzel plus a drink at six stops, and there's a bonus. WDWNT found a Marshmallow Mickey Head with chocolate and peppermint on the welcome trail Sunday. It wasn't on the treat list Disney shared Nov. 4.
The six stops, with the drinks WDWNT and MickeyBlog found on opening night:
The Lunching Pad: Snickerdoodle Cookie and punch
Cosmic Ray's Starlight Cafe: Buttercream Frosted Green Sprinkle Cutout Cookie and Joffrey's hot cocoa
Tortuga Tavern: Buttercream Frosted Candy Cane Flavored Cookie and Joffrey's hot cocoa
Sunshine Tree Terrace: Hot Cocoa Cookie made with Dove chocolate and apple cider
Gaston's Tavern: Snowman-shaped Pretzel and apple cider. WDWNT said Gaston's warmed it up first.
Storybook Circus Train Station: Cookie Dough Buttercream Frosted Cookie and eggnog
Each stop has an allergy-friendly packaged cookie or pretzel on request. There's no allergy-friendly drink, WDWNT said, but you can ask for water.
Can day guests buy the Very Merry party food?
Mostly no. Disney's foodie guide marks nearly every item party-only.
The exceptions are at The Plaza Restaurant. Its new Classic Reuben, Santa's Floridian Pulled Pork Sandwich and Red Velvet Cheesecake are on the regular menu through Jan. 2, 2027, Disney says. We listed all 14 new items when Disney posted the menu Oct. 29.
Disney's guide warns menus are subject to change. The Pluto cake proved it on night one.
Article compiled and written by Kambrea Pratt (editor-in-chief), Derek Gibbs (beat editor) and the Pirates & Princesses newsroom. Pirates & Princesses is part of WebReef Media.
Pirates and Princesses is your destination for Disney news, theme park updates, and the pop culture you love. From Disney cruises and travel tips to Disney fashion, food, collectibles, and movie news, PNP covers it all. Visit us at piratesandprincesses.net for daily coverage. Follow PNP on Facebook and Instagram, and listen to the Pirates & Princesses podcast on Apple Podcasts and YouTube.
Hat Tips:
WDW News Today (Nov. 8, 2026), opening-night review rankings and prices, the complimentary treat and drink list and the welcome trail treat
Disney Food Blog (Nov. 8, 2026), opening-night reviews and prices of all new items and the Pluto Reindeer Cake pause
MickeyBlog (Nov. 8, 2026), reviews of the Winter Wonderland Express, Mickey the Elf and Minnie Cocoa Cake, plus the free drinks
Disney Parks Blog (Oct. 29, 2026), official item names and which items are party-only
AI Disclosure: All articles are assigned, edited and reviewed by an experienced human editor before posting. Like most modern newsrooms, WebReef Media uses a variety of AI tools to help with accuracy and efficiency. Ways AI may be used in article creation include research, grammar, fact-checking and ideation, as well as occasional AI generated or enhanced thumbnails or graphics. No articles are generated or posted without human oversight or involvement.



